Dessert Match-Ups: Part 1

Food

The sweeter of the teeth

Published

June 5, 2026

Figure 1: Votes and shares for each question (faceted).

How decisive were these results, combined?

TL;DR: Ice Cream demolished Frozen Yogurt (65–11, 86%) — the most lopsided result of any dessert this series. Layered was a nail-biter: Crème Brulee over Tiramisu by just 3 votes.

question N Leader (votes) Trailer (votes) Leader share Margin (votes) Margin (points) p vs 50/50 Leader 95% CI Votes to flip
Creamy 71 Mousse (44) Pudding (27) 62.0% 17 23.9% 0.0568 [0.50, 0.73] 9
Frozen 76 Ice Cream (65) Frozen Yogurt (11) 85.5% 54 71.1% 0.0000 [0.76, 0.93] 28
Fruity 74 Pie (42) Cobbler (32) 56.8% 10 13.5% 0.2950 [0.45, 0.68] 6
Layered 73 Crème Brulee (38) Tiramisu (35) 52.1% 3 4.1% 0.8150 [0.40, 0.64] 2
Stuffed 71 Cannoli (45) Éclair (26) 63.4% 19 26.8% 0.0319 [0.51, 0.75] 10
Figure 2: Leader shares with 95% confidence intervals.

Does HQ agree with RTP?

question Leader (overall) HQ share RTP share Gap (pts) p-value
Creamy Mousse 56% (28/50) 76% (16/21) 20% 0.183
Frozen Ice Cream 83% (44/53) 91% (21/23) 8% 0.556
Fruity Pie 63% (32/51) 43% (10/23) 19% 0.195
Layered Crème Brulee 52% (27/52) 52% (11/21) 0% 1.000
Stuffed Cannoli 61% (30/49) 68% (15/22) 7% 0.767
Figure 3: HQ vs RTP support for each question’s overall winner.

The Alignment Index bounces back a bit this week to 0.65 — still below Earth Day’s opening 0.90, but a recovery from last week’s dip — with the cumulative number at 0.85. Creamy produced the widest single-question office gap we’ve seen yet, 20% — both offices preferred Mousse, RTP just felt more strongly about it.

The more interesting story is in Fruity. RTP’s votes actually crowned a different winner than the whiteboard as a whole: while the combined total favored Pie, RTP alone preferred Cobbler. It’s not statistically significant with these sample sizes, but it’s the first time in the RTP era that the two offices would have crowned different desserts if they’d each voted alone.